KNEEtalk

The WAITING ROOM => GENERAL KNEE QUESTIONS and comments (good for new threads) => Topic started by: sparkle999 on April 29, 2005, 12:44:21 PM

Title: good news and bad news
Post by: sparkle999 on April 29, 2005, 12:44:21 PM
I just saw my OS this morning. He's going to do a scope to clear out the knee (won't bend 6 weeks after injury) and get the loose floaty thing out and have a go at bending it while I'm under anasthetic. I am scared about this but he says he'll have had a good look first and will be able to determine what it is that's preventing the knee from bending.

This does mean my recon will not be for at least another 8 weeks from now, all being well. It's a pain because I was hoping to be back fully fit by September when the teachihg year starts again.

Has anyone has a scope like this??
Is it okay for him to bend it under anasthetic or is that what's called a MUA that I hear so many horror stories about.

Please reassure me if you can
xx

(PS The good news bit was that he didn't just send me away for more PT. And he was PLEASED I'd done some research and he was really sympathetic and respectful, which I didn't feel he was last time)
Title: Re: good news and bad news
Post by: stgiles16 on April 29, 2005, 02:23:51 PM
MUA is manipulation under anst. and that is partly what you are describing. The good thing is that he will scope it first to determine the problem. I have never had an MUA so I cant comment on that but just the sound of it makes me nervous. Hope someone with experience can help you.

good luck
missy
Title: Re: good news and bad news
Post by: Linds on April 29, 2005, 02:35:25 PM
Hey, Sparkle...
 Well it is good news that your OS sounds really great. ;D Always good to have someone like that in you corner.  I too hope somoene whos had an MUA will resond to this post.
I did want to say though, that it's great that your OS is going to take a look around first, and sometimes it's easier to examine the knee with the patient out, because you can't guard (conciously or subconciously) the knee, so he can really get a good look at what's going on.

GOODLUCK

Linds
Title: Re: good news and bad news
Post by: Patty0513 on April 29, 2005, 03:20:45 PM
Hi Sparkle,
   I have had several manipulations, I just skip the anesthesia part.  It is not that bad.  Since he is going in with the scope he should be able to release a lot of the scar tissue first and them gently bend the knee to further break it up.  A lot of people don't like this procedure, but I have never had any problems with it other than it hurts like the dickens!!   :)  Let me know if you have any questions! 

Good Luck!
Patty
Title: Re: good news and bad news
Post by: hottubpam on April 29, 2005, 08:28:04 PM
Sorry Sparkle I cannot reassure you about the MUA.  I had one (along with a partial lysis of adhesion).  For me the MUA can only be described as a barbaric procedure and I will never consent to one again.  The MUA was done on me 8 months after original injury and 7 months after my ACL reconstruction so the scar tissue had enough time to harden.  There is hope that your scar tissue is still relatively pliable and therefore an MUA will not be as traumatic as it was for me.  Enter MUA on the search engine of this bulletin board and you will find lots of info from people (both pro and con) that have had MUA's. 

It wouldn't hurt to get a second opinion before you undergo the MUA.

Good luck,
Pam
Title: Re: good news and bad news
Post by: smiley196 on April 29, 2005, 09:36:54 PM
Sparkle-
Well im glad to hear that you finally got a scope and can hopefully get things sorted out! Good luck!!
krista
Title: Re: good news and bad news
Post by: Teresa_S on April 30, 2005, 02:02:51 AM
I, too had the MUA , after lysis of adhesions through the scope. I believe that is the only way I have seen them scheduled in the multiple hospitals where I have worked. The ones done under IV sedation, or without sedation, I HOPE< are more like an osteopathic manipulation, and done easily and not forcefully. Teresa
Title: Re: good news and bad news
Post by: sparkle999 on April 30, 2005, 08:13:24 AM
Thanks for all your comments. i do have more questions though.

When I said to my OS 'is this called a manipulation under anaesthesia' he said that it was really more 'part of the proceedure of the scope' to clear out the knee then see if that allowed it to bend.

He did try to play it down and also said that 'to try to bend the knee without a scope' was very foolish, as all the facts were not known. This SOUNDED quite sensible and concurred with lots of posts on this site. One thing though, I did look up MUA and there was a post from someone who was really pleased with their progress after MUA. Some replies said not to be so confident as 'you're not out of the woods yet'. What was this comment referring to do you think?? How long after can problems surface? Would you know within a couple of weeks ,say?

My OS wants to keep me on overnight on a CPM after the scope. Anyone had this before??

XX

Title: Re: good news and bad news
Post by: Janet on April 30, 2005, 04:16:59 PM
It sounds like he is doing everything right. First, he isn't really doing a MUA. He's doing a clean-out through the scope, then will gently bend your knee to make sure it moves correctly and there is nothing else inhibiting the bend. This is exactly how it should be done. And being on a CPM is even more proof that he knows what he's doing. Then it's a matter of taking things slowly and gently in rehab to keep the swelling and irritation down, gently moving the knee a lot through your ROM to keep the flexion you gain from the surgery, keeping the quad firing (but not necessarily strengthening) while your knee is still sore....all this will help prevent scar tissue from reforming. Remember to elevate your knee above your heart and your ankle above your knee and to ice regularly to keep the knee happy! Good luck.

Janet
Title: Re: good news and bad news
Post by: Teresa_S on April 30, 2005, 09:22:28 PM
I agree that is it nice for you to be able to stay overnight and utilize the CPM as where I have had mine, they can't wait for me to open my eyes, and suck down a swallow of water, and then they tell me to put on my clothes, and they push me out to the c ar to go home.  Hope you do well ,and this is a solution to your pain and problems. Teresa
Title: Re: good news and bad news
Post by: upset mom on May 02, 2005, 04:10:34 AM
Hi Sparkle,

I said a prayer for you when I read your post!  Hope and pray this procedure turns out to be a positive thing towards your full recovery and that you are up and about before too long.   

Lisa